The Cost of Investment vs the Cost of Inaction
Commercial printing executives face a persistent challenge: operating in a highly competitive, low-margin environment where the difference between profit and loss often hinges on minor operational variances. When facing tight margins and intense market pressure, the decision to hire an external consultant can feel like a significant cost. However, I propose that in today’s evolving industry, engaging external experts for a professional business assessment is not a cost, but a strategic investment.
The true financial danger lies in the Cost of Inaction; the steady, silent erosion of profitability that results from avoiding a necessary health check.
The Cost of Consulting: A High-Return Investment
When considering consulting fees, print company owners often cite concerns regarding cost, time, and operational disruption. These are valid concerns, but they must be weighed against the overwhelming evidence of quantifiable financial gains.
Hiring an external consultant provides specialized expertise and an unbiased perspective that insiders, often too engrossed in day-to-day operations, simply cannot offer. While many business leaders make decisions based on intuition, consultants deliver strategies based on data and facts.
The investment in consulting services is often self-funding. Financial results from the commercial printing industry demonstrate that the gains overwhelmingly justify the costs. For instance, some consulting firms are so confident in their ability to deliver value that they guarantee a minimum ROI of 4:1—meaning at least $4 in savings or profit improvement for every $1 spent.
Furthermore, objections regarding time and disruption are often mitigated by experienced consultants who conduct observations and interviews without halting production. The short-term management of change is a small price to pay for long-term improvements that free up management time and reduce chaos.
The Cost of Inaction: Hidden Waste and Competitive Decline
Choosing the status quo—avoiding a professional, objective assessment—exposes a commercial printing company to massive, compounding risks. This is the true "cost of inaction."
1. Hidden Waste and Profit Leakage
The most insidious risk is the continuation of hidden waste and profit leakage. Hidden workflow inefficiencies—such as manual job handling, rework, and inconsistent estimating—can silently drain an estimated 10–20% of a print shop’s annual revenue. In an industry where average net profit margins are typically only 1–3%, allowing such leakage to persist can be the difference between thriving and merely surviving. Avoiding an assessment means choosing to ignore these leaking buckets.
2. Stagnation and Lost Market Share
If profits are flat or declining, unresolved inefficiencies or unaddressed market shifts are likely the cause. Failing to adapt means falling behind industry best practices.
-
Competitive Disadvantage: Competitors who invest in assessments will improve their cost structures and turnaround times, enabling them to undercut on price or win more customers.
-
Missed Opportunities: The printing industry is continually evolving (digital transformation, packaging growth). Without external input, a company risks missing emerging revenue streams by sticking to familiar, shrinking product lines. Consultants can highlight, for example, lucrative opportunities in packaging or large-format signage that a traditional printer is overlooking.
3. Financial Crisis and Business Decline
Ignoring minor issues allows them to accumulate into a major financial crisis. One vivid case involved a family-run commercial printer that experienced operating losses in five out of six years and was veering toward insolvency. This required an emergency, painful turnaround, which involved drastic measures like asset sales and workforce reduction, simply because management had not effectively addressed declining sales and rising costs sooner. Inaction can lead to crisis—a far more painful and costly scenario than proactive assessment.
The ROI Equation: Measurable Gains Across the Business
The power of external consultants lies in their ability to target both short-term operational improvements and long-term strategic positioning.
Operational Excellence: Immediate Financial Impact
Operations consulting focuses intensely on optimizing internal processes and workflows to enhance productivity and increase profit margins through decreased costs. These engagements typically deliver short-to-medium-term improvements (a few months to a year) with tangible, measurable outcomes.
The results are substantial:
-
Productivity and Throughput: External analysis can identify surprising bottlenecks. For example, one firm discovered supervisors were spending 60% of their time on administrative tasks instead of on the production floor, leading to a "passive supervisory culture". Correcting this led to a 31% increase in labor productivity and a 24% increase in throughput.
-
Massive Cost Reduction: The productivity gains mentioned above translated directly to $4.9 million in annual savings. Another firm saved $4.8 million per year by implementing robust project management solutions guided by consultants.
-
Technology Optimization: Consultants ensure printing firms fully utilize their equipment. Through process tweaks, one engagement improved press machine speeds by 29% and cut job changeover times by 38%. Consultants also advise on implementing automation and Print MIS (Management Information Systems) to streamline workflows.
Strategic Alignment: Securing Future Growth
Strategy consulting takes a holistic view of the organization, focusing on long-term planning and external market factors that drive growth. Success here is measured by outcomes like market share growth, revenue increases, or successful market entry.
Consultants use their broad industry perspective to conduct competitive benchmarking and market research. For example, a consulting firm helped a client assess new specialty markets outside its traditional commodity print business. This resulted in an opportunity scorecard and clear recommendations on which high-value segments to pursue, giving the client a roadmap to expand into more profitable areas. Strategy consultants are invaluable when considering entering new markets, launching new products, or conducting comprehensive competitive analyses.
The Synergy of Strategy and Operations
For maximum efficiency, commercial print executives should seek partners who can provide both operations and strategy support. Strategy defines where the company should go (e.g., entering the packaging market), and operations ensures the internal processes (technology, staffing, quality control) are optimized to make that strategic move successful. This integrated approach prevents delays and ensures strategic plans are quickly implemented based on operational realities.
In the printing world, this coordination is essential: operations consultants address spiraling costs and quality control issues, while strategy consultants help anticipate competitive moves and mitigate strategic risks.
A Call to Action for Print Executives
The financial gains from proactive assessment are undeniable, often providing a rapid payback period, with some turnarounds achieving profitability within one month.
To set your commercial printing company on a course of sustainable growth and operational excellence, you must recognize the improvement opportunity.
-
Acknowledge Internal Blind Spots: Begin with an honest reflection: Are recurring issues (missed deadlines, rising costs, quality complaints) going unresolved? Even successful businesses have blind spots that professional insight can unlock.
-
Research and Identify Qualified Partners: Look for consulting firms with specific experience in the printing or manufacturing sector who can guarantee results. The ideal partner understands the challenges of high-volume printing operations.
-
Schedule an Exploratory Assessment: Many firms offer initial consultations or diagnostic studies that require minimal commitment. Use this to obtain a tailored proposal that highlights specific inefficiencies and projected outcomes (e.g., expected cost savings).
Don't wait for internal issues to compound into a financial crisis. The cost of paying a consultant pales in comparison to the cost of enduring continuous hidden waste and eventual market stagnation. By acting now, the efficiency gains and strategic improvements effectively “pay” for the consulting service, delivering ongoing returns long after the engagement is complete.